TBP 320: Crimp Smarter – The Hand Muscles People Ignore, with Dr. Jared Vagy
Dr. Jared Vagy, “The Climbing Doctor,” is back on the podcast to talk about crimping. Specifically, he covers the finger and hand muscles most climbers never train, and why that might matter for your pulleys and overall hand health.
Jared has a new book, The Resilient Climber, which breaks down 40 climbing movements by their mobility, strength, and movement demands. In this episode he applies that framework to the crimp. His core argument: climbers train their long finger flexors in one direction, over and over. That’s a lot like runners who build huge quads and hamstrings but neglect the side-hip muscles that stabilize the knee. The smaller stabilizing muscles in the hand get left behind, and Jared sees that pattern constantly in injured climbers.
It might be easier to watch the video rather than just listen so you can see our hands for demonstration throughout:
In this episode:
- Why hangboarding trains only two muscles (FDS and FDP), and how stronger flexors put more load on your pulleys
- The finger extensors: why they co-contract when you grip, and how to train them in a crimp position
- The “finger split”: why your pointer finger may drift away from your middle finger when you crimp, and why you should video yourself on a hangboard
- A simple test for palmar interossei weakness, plus the pom-pom squeeze exercise (and what it means if the pom-poms fall out)
- Why trad climbers tend to have stronger hand intrinsics than climbers who only sport climb
- The lumbricals: the muscles behind the “cup” in your crimp, and why they can produce grip force without running under the pulleys
- How to train lumbricals: the lumbrical wave, pinch training, slopers, wide hand jams, and a DIY crack block
- Finger mobility for long-time climbers: “motion is lotion,” pen rolling, and Jared’s tissue-wrapped pen tool
- How to target one stiff finger joint with traction, using a finger trap and the edge of a yoga block
Links
- The Climbing Doctor: Jared’s site, with free blog posts and programs
- The Resilient Climber
- Climb Injury-Free
- Videos from the episode:
- Jared sees climbers in person in Los Angeles and does remote sessions for climbers in CO, UT, and CA. He also keeps a referral list of climbing-savvy providers on his site.
Note: the traction and loading exercises in this episode are general education. Check with a medical provider before trying them, especially if you’re injured.
Other Interviews with Dr. Vagy
- Interview #1: We talked in general about how to heal injuries, but since that time he has gotten way more specific about the steps we need to take to address them.
- Interview #2: He talked about how to heal shoulder impingement.
- Interview #3: We talked about rotator cuff injuries and neck strain.
- Interview #4: We discussed finger pulley sprains.
- Interview #5: We discussed elbow injuries.
- Interview #6: We talked about hip injuries.
- Interview #7: Finger Injuries and Protocols
- Interview #8: How to deal with Finger Capsulitis
Jared Vagy Professional Credentials
Dr. Vagy is an authority on climbing related injuries. He has published numerous articles on injury prevention and delivers lectures and seminars on the topic. He received his Doctorate in Physical Therapy (DPT) from the University of Southern California, ranked the number one DPT Program in the nation for the last decade by US News and World Report.
He is now a professor at the University in the DPT Program. As a Doctor of Physical Therapy in clinical practice, he went on to complete a one-year residency program in orthopedics and a one-year fellowship program in movement science. He is a Board Certified Orthopedic Clinical Specialist and a Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist.

Please Review The Podcast on iTunes
Please give the podcast an honest review on iTunes here to help the show reach more curious climbers around the world.
Transcript
Intro, Jared’s background, and The Resilient Climber (00:00)
Neely: Okay, welcome back to the show, Jared. Thanks so much for talking with me again.
Jared: Yeah, it’s technically been a while, so it’s good to be back on the podcast.
Neely: Yes and no. We had a little recording mishap, unfortunately. We did a whole episode, which we will do again at some point on a different topic. But today, what are we talking about? People love your episodes. So what body parts are we talking about today?
Jared: We’re talking specifically about crimping, because that’s almost an entire episode. And then if we have time, we’ll get into drop knees as well.
For context, the reason we’re picking climbing movements is that I wrote a new book called The Resilient Climber. The book breaks down 40 different climbing movements. So I wanted to pick apart movements the way they’re shown in the book, and break them down into ways to improve mobility, strength, and performance, and reduce the risk of injury for each one. And why not talk about crimping? It’s one of the most common moves, or grips, I guess, that we use while climbing.
Neely: Yeah, right. And a lot of us are getting injured while doing it. So it makes sense that we’d want to know how to do it correctly and watch out for anything we’re doing wrong.
Jared: Yeah, and there’s really not a wrong component. But I’ve seen thousands of climbers with injuries, and there’s a lot I notice that I think people listening may want to stay tuned in for.
Neely: And for more context, in case people haven’t listened to your other eight to ten appearances on this podcast, can you tell us who you are?
Jared: Yeah. My name is Jared Vagy. I’m a doctor of physical therapy and an associate professor at the University of Southern California. I rock climb, I treat climbers, and I’ve written a few books on the topic. I love climbing, talking about it, and trying to reduce injury risk and increase performance for climbers, in a nutshell. I’m based in Los Angeles, but I travel around quite a bit.
Neely: Travel around doing what? Climbing clinics?
Jared: Both. I wear a lot of different hats. With my university hat, I travel around teaching lectures and seminars all over the world on athlete movement. And I’ve been really fortunate to also travel to teach lectures and seminars on climbing itself and how to rehabilitate climbing injuries.
Neely: Oh, yeah. You’re kind of the guy.
Jared: A lot of people call me the OG, because I’ve been doing this for about 15 years. When I first started, I was writing magazine articles. That’s how prehistoric the knowledge was at that stage. And now, which is really cool, I’m teaching clinics, lectures, and courses to other medical providers who treat climbers. So there are more and more people doing this, which is amazing.
Neely: It is amazing. It’s crazy to see how it’s grown, even in the past seven years. I have a hand specialist here, and I’ve sent a million climbers to her. Now she says 80% of her practice is climbers, and she specializes in pulley injuries. It’s really cool to have resources like that around.
Jared: And a lot has changed. I had a column in a climbing magazine, and when I look back at what I wrote then, there’s been so much research and so much evolution in rehabilitating climbing injuries since. I’m super stoked to share it. Hence this new book.
Anyone who wants to write a book, don’t do it. It’s so much time, effort, energy, and investment. But the payoff is good. I’m really proud of it, and figuring it all out was almost a journey in itself.
Neely: What did you put into figuring it all out?
Jared: The book is based on climbing movements, so it breaks down 40 of them. Take the drop knee, which hopefully we’ll have a chance to talk about later. To do that movement, you need appropriate mobility, the flexibility and motion to get into those positions. And then you need the strength to drop into that position and push out of it. So for every movement, I broke down the mobility demands and strength demands, then came up with tailored exercises for each that are very climbing-specific.
That was the hard part, because my first book, Climb Injury-Free, was all about rehabilitating injuries. I wanted to make sure there was no overlap in exercises or content with this book. It’s all completely new material.
I had tons of help in the process. My first book was independently published. For this one, I had entire teams of people: a publisher, an amazing photographer, editors, multiple shoots in different locations. It was really a team project, with my mind as the engine, which made it even more fulfilling, because I get to share it with the many people who brought it to life.
Neely: That’s incredible, and well deserved. That’s not to say your other books weren’t very professional, with great photos and videos. But this one is even better. Great work.
Jared: Thank you.
Neely: So we’re going to talk about crimping and drop kneeing. You want to start with crimping?
The runner analogy (07:20)
Jared: Yeah, I want to start with crimping and the hands in general, because there are a lot of things I notice with climbers who come in, and I think it’s an issue across the board. I’ll use an analogy.
I’ve worked a lot with runners, and still do. Running is obviously a lot different from climbing. But runners would come in with knee pain from the repetitive forces of running. A lot of them were at very high levels, Olympic or professional. I’d assess the muscles in their body with a tool called a dynamometer, which measures how much force they can generate with their leg muscles.
With a lot of these runners, I noticed they were really strong in their quadriceps, the big thigh muscles, in their hamstrings, and in their calves. Those are all muscles whose primary job is to propel you forward. But they had a pretty asymmetric weakness, comparatively, in the side hip muscles that control the pelvis. You see this a lot with runners. Why? Because all they’re doing is running in a straight line, so that’s what they’re training over time.
But the knee is a three-dimensional body region. The side hip muscles control micro movements side to side, even if that’s a centimeter with each step. So if you strengthen those side hip muscles and make the body a bit more resilient, they can have a better stride. They take demand off their quadriceps and hamstrings, and they can run better.
You may see where I’m going with climbers. What are we always using to grip the hold?
Neely: Our fingers.
Jared: Our fingers, and we’re doing that repetitively. And in our training, what are climbers doing to train their fingers? Neely, what do you do, or what do you see climbers do?
Neely: They hang on their fingers.
Jared: They hang on their fingers, typically in one direction. Either their arms are over their head, or they’re pulling from the ground. They add more and more load or longer hang durations, and they make the edge smaller and smaller.
It’s such a simple concept, but it baffles me. There are multiple muscles in the fingers that control side-to-side micro movements, and even forward-and-back motion, that stabilize the fingers. They’re not the long finger flexors, and climbers don’t touch them or have any awareness of them.
It blows my mind, because I see this pattern time and time again. Climbers come in with finger injuries, I look at their hand, finger, and wrist as a whole, and they’ve strengthened only two sets of muscles. The stabilizers, the adjacent musculature, are weak and underdeveloped, and that could potentially lead to problems.
So that’s the 30,000-foot view. Climbers are like these runners, constantly running in one plane of motion. We’re constantly training our fingers one way, and there may be another piece of the puzzle missing.
Neely: Do you feel like that directly contributes to injuries? I feel like people hang and train their fingers so they don’t get injured. Do you find that people who train everything else in their hands don’t get injured as much?
Jared: It’s like these runners doing heavy squats and lunges to train their legs to absorb impact, but missing part of the puzzle. Now, I can’t take a magic ball and tell you that making the body more resilient prevents injuries. I can’t tell you that. But it likely reduces the risk if you can improve the adjacent muscles’ ability to support the fingers, so you’re not overloading the same two specific muscles time and time again. I can only tell you what I notice clinically.
There’s climbing, and then there’s training. A lot of climbing training is one direction of pull, repeated over time. Climbers who project are the same: you’re repeatedly pulling in one direction, maybe slightly to the side, but doing the same thing over and over. So what I want to introduce is some variability.
Long finger flexors and pulleys (13:30)
Neely: Okay, so what are the muscles we’re all training, and what are the ones you want people to train?
Jared: The muscles climbers constantly train are the long finger flexors. They originate in the forearm, which is obviously why climbers have a lot of forearm mass, among other things. The muscle bellies in the forearm turn into tendons as they run through the hand and fingers. There are two of them.
Flexor digitorum profundus has a long tendon that inserts at the tip of the fingers. Flexor digitorum superficialis has a tendon that splits and attaches at the middle of the finger. So imagine long strings or rubber bands running to each finger, connected to a muscle belly. One stops midway through the finger, and one goes all the way to the tip. These are the main muscles we generate force with when we grip.
It’s easier to call them FDS (flexor digitorum superficialis) and FDP (flexor digitorum profundus). Those are our main flexor muscles.
Neely: Are people actually injuring those muscles? I almost always hear about people injuring their tendons or pulleys.
Jared: It’s rarely the muscle belly. It’s not even the tendon itself, unless there’s a cut or laceration, or a very rare injury where a foot pops and there’s a shock load.
It’s the pulleys. Imagine you’re climbing an overhanging sport route, and the quickdraws keep the rope flush to the wall. Those are our pulleys. We have five annular pulleys that keep the flexor tendons flush to the bone. If the force through the flexor tendons is too much for the annular pulleys to sustain, you get the most common climbing injury, which is a pulley rupture.
So these tendons and muscles are being strengthened in climbers, and as you strengthen them, they put more and more stress on the pulleys. That can be positive: the pulleys adapt and you get stronger. Or it can be negative: they can’t adapt, they’re overloaded, and you have a rupture.
Neely: So what do you think people should be doing to strengthen everything in the best way possible?
Jared: I think the question is, what else is there to strengthen? What else is going on in the hand besides the pulleys and the long flexors? I call FDS and FDP long flexors because they run from the forearm all the way to the fingers, so they have bigger levers. But there are other muscles in the hand, and those are the ones I’d like climbers to investigate, to see if they can improve strength and stability.
I notice more and more that finger position while crimping plays a large role in overuse and overstress of the pulleys. I’ll shelve that for a moment. I always look at movement. When climbers come in with finger injuries, like a pulley injury, I watch them crimp, and there’s often something common I notice. That’s where these stabilizing muscles come into play, to clean up the gripping motion and take load off the pulleys.
Finger extensors (18:00)
Jared: Neely, can you guess what the other muscles in the fingers do? Then I can guide you to which muscles they are.
Neely: Given what you said about the runners, they move our fingers side to side instead of down.
Jared: Exactly, lateral. And there’s one particular set of muscles that works together to move the fingers forward at the lowest knuckle joint. That’s a group of three muscles we’ll talk about. But first, let’s talk about the ones that move the fingers backward: the finger extensors.
Put your palm facing the ground and lift one finger up, separated from the others. That’s one of your finger extensors. Extensor digitorum communis is the large one. You have a separate one for your pointer finger and another for your pinky.
Neely, why are those important when we climb? In the simplest sense, if you turned on that muscle while gripping, your finger would slip off the hold. So why are finger extensors important for gripping?
Neely: I have no idea. Maybe it’s the same reason you work your triceps as well as your biceps, so one doesn’t get out of balance?
Jared: I pondered this for a while too. You’d think they’re antagonist muscles and we just want to balance the body. But that’s not actually true for the finger extensors. When we grip a hold, we co-contract our finger extensors and wrist extensors at the same time as our flexors. So we’re developing tone in those muscles too, and they control the micro movement of the fingers forward and back.
Imagine coming up onto a crimp. You don’t hold a position like a snapshot. There are small shifts of the fingers back and forth, and part of that is the flexors in front and the extensors in back coordinating those micro adjustments.
Neely: That makes so much sense. Of course.
Jared: So when a climber comes in with a finger injury, I assess the strength of these muscles. Control is a big thing too; sometimes it’s not even strength. If they don’t have much strength or control, we can improve the capacity of these muscles and their timing. That can take some stress off the muscles in front, or help position the finger more ideally when crimping.
The interesting thing is how you train it. You don’t straighten your fingers and move them up and down. You train the finger extensors in a crimp position, moving them in and out against some resistance. That motion comes mostly from the lowest knuckle joint up to the second knuckle joint, called the PIP.
Neely: How do you do that?
Jared: An easy way is to slide your hand onto a flat surface, like a yoga block. Bend your fingers into a half crimp, then slide your hand off so your knuckles are right at the edge, with that first bone of your fingers hanging off the block. Then either put some weight there and hold it isometrically, or loop a thick resistance band over your fingers and pull it down. Now you’re controlling that very small micro movement right at the fingers.
Neely: That makes sense. It won’t make as much sense if you’re just listening on audio, but I’m assuming it’s very clear in your book.
Jared: We can put a link in the show notes so people can see what it looks like. That’s a way to train the finger extensors the way they work in action.
Neely: So that’ll give you more control in your crimping, which could potentially help you avoid injury, I’d assume.
Jared: It’s possible. I think it’s helpful, but the more helpful one is the side-to-side motion.
The finger split and the palmar interossei (23:10)
Jared: That’s where I see a lot of differences and challenges: the fingers starting to split or deviate when we crimp.
Imagine this, Neely. A climber is on a fingerboard, hanging with their hands overhead on a 20 mm edge, and they have an injury on their right middle finger. You look at their left and right sides, and as they hang, you see a split starting to open between their pointer finger and their middle finger. How would you describe that?
Neely: Space between the pointer finger and the middle finger.
Jared: Yeah, almost a gapping. If I see that, I need to assess why they’re doing it asymmetrically. Climbers don’t know this at all. Especially with the arms overhead, you don’t see your fingers, so you think you’re gripping symmetrically. But I have hundreds, if not thousands, of videos of this happening across different digits and positions.
There are different reasons climbers may do this. Some of it is anthropometrics, like digit length. Some is movement patterns, some is strength, and some is further down the chain: wrist position, elbow, shoulder.
Neely, I see you playing around with it right now.
Neely: Yeah, I’m trying it. How do I do it?
Jared: If anyone listening wants to check, have your climbing partner take a video of your fingers on a fingerboard. You may be surprised by what you see.
I’m not saying a split in the fingers is 100% going to cause an injury. I’m saying I see a correlation between an injury on one finger and the adjacent finger splitting away from it. So I can hypothesize that there may be a muscle weakness or a movement imbalance that doesn’t let them create symmetric forces when they crimp.
I can confirm that hypothesis in the clinic. If they have pain while hanging, I stabilize the finger by bringing it back together. If their pain goes down and they can grip harder, that’s a useful guide.
So if the finger is splitting, what could it be? One possibility is a movement pattern, a habit developed over time. Like a runner who runs with one foot toed out for years and never notices, a climber can develop a finger that splays to the side.
Or it can be muscle weakness. These are the interossei, the muscles between the bones of the hand, between almost each digit. The ones that pull the fingers inward are called the palmar interossei. When they’re weak, they may not be able to hold the finger inward when you crimp at maximal force.
Neely: So what do you do about that?
Jared: First, I need to test them and see if there’s weakness. It’s simple. The climber squeezes their fingers together as tight as they can, and I gently try to separate them, imagining that finger splitting from the middle finger. I go in at each knuckle and try to splay the fingers apart, to see if the climber can hold them together against my resistance.
Neely: And then what? Would you have them do something like…
Jared: Oh, now you want the solution. As a clinician, you have to be very honest with this test, because I can overpower any climber’s fingers with my arms by grabbing their fingertips and splaying them apart. But I’ve tested enough fingers to know the amount of force, which is actually very gentle. I go to the middle knuckle joint, so it’s a longer lever, and gently try to separate the fingers. If I can separate them with very little effort, especially compared to the other hand, there’s potentially weakness in the palmar interossei. We may need to strengthen them to balance out the grip and make it more symmetrical.
So how would you do this, Neely? Say you have a middle finger injury, and your pointer finger splits away from your middle finger when you crimp. I tested the muscles, and they’re weak. They’re not letting your pointer finger come inward. We retested, and you got stronger and had less pain when your pointer finger was close to your middle finger. So now we need an exercise to strengthen those muscles. Any guesses how you could strengthen your fingers coming inward?
Neely: I can’t figure out how to do it inward. I can figure out outward.
Jared: How would you do it outward?
Neely: I’d put a rubber band around two fingers and separate them. Or a hair tie.
Jared: Yeah, a hair tie or rubber band. That strengthens the dorsal interossei, which spread the fingers outward. You can put a twist in the band so it stays on, and even bend your fingers a bit so it mimics crimping. I 100% agree that makes sense for strengthening them outward. How do you strengthen them inward?
Neely: I guess you could put something between them.
Jared: Yes, roll with that. Put something between your two fingers and squeeze it. What’s something squishy and easy to put between your fingers?
Neely: A finger from your other hand?
Jared: I guess you could, but it’s a little awkward. You can use cotton balls. But I go to the craft store a lot. I’m not artistic, but I look for rehab tools for climbers. And I found pom-poms. Not the ones you cheer with, but the little ones that look like mini cotton balls and come in all different colors. They’re only about an inch.
Slide pom-poms between each finger and squeeze inward. One of three things usually happens. One, it’s easy, no problem, and your palmar interossei are strong. I don’t see that very often. Two, it’s hard after 30 seconds. Even an elite climber’s hand will be shaking just from squeezing these pom-poms maximally for 30 seconds. Three, the pom-poms fall out.
What do you think the issue is if they’re shaking and can’t squeeze very well?
Neely: That’s easy. Lack of strength.
Jared: Yeah. And what do you think the issue is if the pom-poms fall out? Because that may not be strength.
Neely: It seems like coordination.
Jared: Yes. Each finger is either flexing forward or rotating slightly as you squeeze, which levers the pom-pom out. Your fingers aren’t coordinating. They’re twisting, flexing, or extending with different micro movements, the pom-poms fall out, and you have to pick them up and try again. I think that illustrates the micro movement that happens when we use all our hand and finger muscles, and that’s something you can train too.
You don’t have to do it with your hand in space, either. Get creative. For an open hand, I have climbers squeeze the pom-poms together and then grip a thick water bottle, so it’s a bit like a sloper. You can do the same thing for pulls from the ground: put the pom-poms in, squeeze the fingers together, stabilize, and pull up from the ground. Now you’re turning on most of the muscles in the hands and fingers to stabilize as you flex your fingers.
Neely: That makes sense.
Why trad climbers have stronger hand intrinsics (33:20)
Jared: So my question is, and you may or may not know this: why aren’t climbers training the strength of these adjacent muscles in the fingers? At least from what I see, we only train gripping. It’s not just crimps; it’s pockets, slopers, and pinches too. But it’s rare that I see specific training for the muscles that supplement our gripping. Why do you think that is? Is it culture? Too much work? It doesn’t make sense to people?
Neely: I think it’s just lack of education. Climbers have incorporated all kinds of weird stuff into their training over the years because that’s what you and other people told them to do. And this is honestly the first time you, I, or anybody has talked about this on this podcast.
Jared: It’s interesting, because I love trad climbing and big walls. In trad climbing, you’re climbing cracks, and you literally have to squeeze your fingers together maximally to wedge them into a crack.
What fascinates me is that in people who exclusively sport climb, I see more weakness in these muscles, which are called the intrinsic muscles. More well-rounded climbers who sport climb, trad climb, and boulder have more developed capacity in all these adjacent finger muscles, regardless of their ability level. So on the intake form, I always look at what type of climbing they do.
Some climbers say, “I don’t want to put pom-poms between my fingers and squeeze them. I’ll lose them. It looks silly.” And I say, there are a bunch of ways to train this that don’t involve pom-poms. There’s a hand crack at the gym you’ve never touched. Get good at jamming in that crack, and now you’re strengthening the muscles that pull the fingers inward, plus another muscle I’ll talk about in a moment. You don’t have to do specific training. You can do more global, functional hand training.
Neely: Opening our eyes here. Now everyone’s going to become a crack climber, I guess. What I’m hearing is that trad climbers have the strongest fingers.
Jared: The strongest lateral stabilizing muscles in the fingers, yeah.
Lumbricals and the cup in your crimp (36:30)
Jared: That brings me to one other thing. We talked about the finger extensors, which bring the fingers up. We talked briefly about the abductors, which spread the fingers, where you mentioned using a rubber band. And we talked about the adductors, which pull them inward. There’s one other set of muscles that’s extremely important in how climbers crimp: the lumbricals.
They work together with the interossei. When I talk about them, I’ll just say “lumbricals” because it’s easier for listeners. But just know that the lumbricals co-contract with the interossei to get into the position I’m about to show you.
Neely, show me how you crimp, from a side view. Okay, Neely’s holding up her hand. Her fingertip joints are curled, and her lowest knuckle joint is flexed forward a little. Neely, have you ever seen anyone crimp exactly like you, but with their lowest knuckle joint pulled back? How would you describe the difference?
Neely: I feel like that’s a more open-hand grip.
Jared: More open-hand, but you’re still maximally flexing the last two joints of your fingers. How would you describe that subtle difference?
Neely: From what I can feel, I feel it less in my palm when I’m straight up and down. It’s less cupped.
Jared: Yeah. So you’re crimping with more of a cup or less of a cup at that lowest knuckle joint. Does that paint a picture for people listening? So which muscles are responsible for that cup?
Neely: I’m assuming it’s the lumbricals.
Jared: Darn it, I led you there too easily. And that may not necessarily be a strength thing. It’s proprioceptive, meaning knowing where your fingers are in space and choosing that position. Climbers crimp with all different amounts of cup in their knuckles.
What I find fascinating is: what if a climber, instead of cupping through the lowest knuckle, flexed down with the middle knuckle? To get pressure onto a hold, one option is to come forward with the lowest knuckle, the one closest to the palm, to dig the fingers in. Another option is to flex the middle knuckle. So why do some climbers crimp with more cup at that lowest knuckle, and why do some flex more through the PIP joint, the second knuckle? It has to do with which muscles they choose to bias when crimping.
Neely: I wonder if it also has to do with pinky length.
Jared: Finger length plays a huge role in how you crimp, whether that’s pinky length, the difference between your second and fourth digit lengths, or global length: your fingers relative to your palm, a short palm or a long palm. There are all these variations.
But one thing I can tell you from anatomy: there’s something different about the muscles that flex the middle finger joint, the PIP, and the muscles that flex the lowest finger joint, the MCP.
What am I doing right now? I’m waving with my knuckles.
Neely: You’re saying bye-bye.
Jared: Bye-bye. I’m waving with my knuckles, keeping my fingers straight, and flexing at the lowest knuckle joint near the palm. That muscle is the lumbrical. Now I’m flexing only the PIP, the second knuckle from the palm. That muscle is flexor digitorum superficialis. The difference between those two muscles is that one runs underneath the pulleys and one doesn’t. Which one do you think goes under the pulleys?
Neely: The flexor.
Jared: Yeah, the long finger flexor we talked about at the top of the podcast runs underneath the pulleys. So the stronger you can get your lumbricals and the associated muscles that create that cup, the harder you can grip with less pulley stress. The lumbricals and the interossei don’t run underneath the pulleys.
Neely: That makes sense. One thing that might help people picture it: I have a friend with a long-standing lumbrical injury, and it gets aggravated when she’s changing her kids’ diapers and holding their feet up with one hand so she can change the diaper with the other. It’s that kind of motion.
Jared: Yes, that’s the motion. Did she injure it climbing?
Neely: I think it was both: taking care of kids and climbing.
Jared: Lumbricals are typically injured in pockets, because you flex one finger and extend the other, and the lumbrical shears. But once they’re injured, they get aggravated in the motion you’re describing, that pinching position with straight fingers.
So the other thing I want to propose is that climbers can strengthen their lumbricals to potentially take stress off their pulleys while gripping.
Neely: How do you do that? Is it just pinch strength training?
Jared: You can isolate it. I have a picture in the book of what’s called a lumbrical wave. You’re basically waving bye-bye: keep your fingers straight and wave from that first knuckle joint. You can fix your hand in place and press into a ball for resistance, so your fingers press back and forth.
Or, as you mentioned, you can just pinch train. Training a stronger pinch may actually help your crimp, because it improves lumbrical and interossei strength, those hand intrinsics. That may be the easy way. Or you can use the pom-poms, or crack climb. There are a bunch of ways to make the hand more resilient to different grips. If you’re always crimping, build in some smaller pinches where your fingers are straight, and that can build some of that lumbrical strength.
Neely: So pinch strength training, diaper changing. Anything else?
Jared: It’s a hard one. Sloper training, depending on the sloper.
[A short section of audio is missing here.]
Jared: There aren’t a ton of ways to train this muscle, because it’s a proprioceptive muscle. But there’s one way I train it, and trad climbers train it quite a bit, and it’s really hard: a #3 or #3.5 crack, meaning a 3- or 3.5-inch crack. You jam your hand in and have to fill the space with your fingers to move up. So it’s a hand jam, but a very wide one. That’s probably one of the best ways to train those muscles, but if you’re not used to it, it can be hard.
If someone’s super motivated, I have a QR code in the book for how to make a crack block out of wood. You can hang weights from it and train your lumbricals.
Neely: Like two blocks together somehow?
Jared: Yeah, two blocks with about three and a half inches between them. You hang weights from them and load the fingers.
Recap (46:50)
Jared: All right, Neely, which muscles did we cover? You don’t have to say the names, just what they do.
Neely: The flexors.
Jared: The long finger flexors, FDP and FDS. They’re constantly being used.
Neely: Then the extensors.
Jared: The extensors: extensor digitorum communis, extensor indicis, and extensor digiti minimi. Those all extend the fingers backward.
Neely: And then, oh no, the inter-something.
Jared: The interossei, palmar and dorsal. They spread the fingers wide and bring them together. And our final one?
Neely: I’m blanking on this word today. I want to say plantar for some reason.
Jared: The lumbricals. They do that bye-bye wave.
So for climbers listening, the question is: can you assess these muscles in your fingers? Can you see whether they have strength and capacity? Can you watch yourself crimp and judge whether those muscles are functioning normally and up to par, or whether there are asymmetries? If there are, I think it’s meaningful to train them, to make your hand and fingers more resilient for climbing.
There are many specific ways to do that, and there are climbing ways too. We talked about hand jams, slopers, and pinches. If you build those into your crimp training, you’ve covered most of those muscles, and that will make your fingers more resilient. If you want pom-poms, rubber bands, resistance bands, and even some weights, that’s a more specific way to target those muscles.
Or if you just want to work on the movement pattern, play with micro-adjusting your fingers under load and see how it feels. See if you have a split in your fingers, and bring the fingers together and apart. Now you’re training the movement.
There’s so much climbers don’t do while they focus only on getting their fingers stronger. That’s really why I wanted to come on today: to emphasize there’s more climbers can try.
Neely: If somebody had a lumbrical injury, would they do some of these exercises, similar to how you’d train through other finger injuries?
Jared: Yes and no. We may need to save that for another podcast, because lumbricals are typically injured in a pocket when the fingers are differentiated, meaning one is flexed and one is extended. That’s completely different from a crimp. In a crimp, that only happens if your pinky pops off. If you have a shorter pinky, or the hold doesn’t fit well, your pinky comes off and differentiates, and you’re almost doing a three-finger crimp.
Neely: I was thinking of the lumbrical exercises you mentioned, like the two blocks with a three-and-a-half-inch gap. Would you do those with a lumbrical injury?
Jared: The answer is yes, but there’s more to it. That’s one part of it.
Neely: Right. That’s the kind of situation where somebody would come see you or a specialist.
Jared: Or we do another episode all about lumbrical injuries and pockets. Pockets are their own thing. We spent about 40 minutes on the crimp, and I could probably talk about it for another five hours. Pockets are the same. There’s a whole level of depth to how these finger muscles work in a pocket, and it’s totally different from crimping.
Neely: Cool. I think that was a really good overview. I learned a lot. I’d never really thought about these muscles except when people tell me they’re injured.
Jared: For people listening, try some of these tests and video your crimp. You may be surprised. The longer we climb, the more habits we develop that we may not be aware of. And there are ways to fix and improve them.
Finger mobility (52:00)
Neely: Cool. Do you want to talk about drop knees? Do you think we have time?
Jared: We can, or I can spend a few more minutes on the fingers if we want to go fully into the fingers. It’s your call, Neely.
Neely: Why don’t we just do fingers, and we’ll do drop knees another time?
Jared: Yeah, I think we could do a whole episode on lower-body movements in climbing. So let’s keep this finger-related. I talked about movement, which is analyzing gripping. I talked about strength. But there’s one other thing we didn’t talk about in the fingers.
Neely: Mobility?
Jared: Mobility. That’s really the basis of the book: it breaks down movement, strength, and mobility, and how they all interact. Finger mobility is kind of an issue. It may not affect our ability to grip holds, but it can definitely cause finger discomfort over time, and even difficulty bending the fingers.
Neely, how long have you been climbing?
Neely: 30 years.
Jared: Three-zero years. How’s your finger mobility? Can you make a claw and touch your fingertips all the way down, and can you extend your knuckles back?
Neely: Yeah, I can. Am I doing it? I don’t know.
Jared: For everyone listening: straighten your hand fully. Make a claw by bringing your fingertips down and try to touch the base of your fingers near the palm, while keeping your lowest knuckle joint extended back. Am I explaining that well enough, Neely?
Neely: Yeah. You’re keeping it straight up and down, but trying to touch your fingertips to your palm.
Jared: And I can see you’re cheating a little. You’re curling your fingers down. It looks a little hard for you to touch your fingertips when you keep your lowest knuckle joint fully straight.
Neely: Well, I have arthritis now in the tips of my fingers.
Jared: So you have some joint challenges in your fingertips. The longer and harder a climber climbs, the more they get what we call osseous, or bone, changes. The cartilage lining changes too, as does the synovium. You get all these changes in the knuckles themselves, so the knuckles become quite stiff in climbers who’ve been climbing a while. Even after an injury, the knuckles can become quite stiff. That becomes an injury in itself. It could be arthritis, or sometimes we call it capsulitis.
So as important as it is to make the fingers resilient from a strength standpoint, we also have to make them more mobile. Neely, what do you do, or what could you do, to keep your fingers from getting that stiff?
Neely: I do these finger curls, like we were just doing, all through the day now. That’s pretty much it. I massage them too.
Jared: Massage gets some blood flow in. And what you’re doing is curling your fingers all the way down to your palm and straightening them. The term is “motion is lotion.” As you bend your fingers, you lubricate those joint surfaces.
Neely: I also sprained this thumb smashing it on a hold, and after going to the hand specialist, I have to hold the first joint of my thumb and then bend it. So I do that a bunch too.
Jared: So you’re isolating motion at a specific joint. There are a lot of ways to work on the fingers. Honestly, how often do you do that per day?
Neely: Oh my God, all the time.
Jared: Like 50 times a day?
Neely: No, maybe five to ten times a day. About ten reps.
Jared: Got it. I like the idea of motion is lotion, but I find it hard for climbers to remember to squeeze their fingers or move them back and forth, because it’s something you have to keep repeating. So I like putting something in their hands. If something’s in your hand, you have to do something with it. You almost have to fidget with it.
Have you tried pen rolling before, Neely? Batoning your pen?
Neely: Oh, that’s interesting. I can’t do that.
Jared: I can’t either. Try it.
Neely: No, I dropped it. It’s on the ground.
Jared: For anyone listening, Neely took a pen, somersaulted it over each finger, and it fell on the ground.
Neely: Immediately.
Jared: Okay. Well, I’ll send a video of this. Take a pen and just roll it up and down your palm. There you go, there’s your backup pen. Roll it back and forth up your palm, starting with your fingers almost like a waterfall. Curl your fingers around it and try different sequences, from your pinky to your ring finger to your middle to your pointer, then reverse, almost fidgeting the pen back and forth.
Neely: Oh, I see. I like that.
Jared: Same concept. But Neely, make sure you get it all the way back. Pull it all the way back so the lowest knuckle joint near your palm is almost extending backward. Now you’re getting motion in the fingers, you’re stretching out the palm, and it’s something you can fidget with, which means you’re more likely to keep doing it over time.
With climbers who have really stiff fingers, that pen may be too thin. Your fingers aren’t that stiff, Neely; they’re pretty good. So I’ll get them a thicker pen or a Sharpie. But some climbers can’t even wrap fully around a Sharpie. So I take tissue paper, like Kleenex, wrap it around the pen in the clinic, and tape all around it. Then I slide the pen out and give it to the climber: “Here’s your fancy custom pen tool,” customized in the clinic, quote unquote.
It’s just thick enough that when they bend into it, they feel a hint of stiffness. Then over time, they use less and less tissue paper and a smaller pen, to get more and more motion in the fingers. It’s a very simple way to get that motion is lotion through the fingers.
Neely: You’re so creative.
Jared: I think this was out of necessity, though. I used to buy wooden dowels of all different diameters at the hardware store and give climbers the right diameter to put in their fingers. No product placement, no ads. Then one day I ran out, and a climber came in with capsulitis who needed a motion exercise. I thought, shoot, I don’t have a dowel. What am I going to do? I looked around the clinic, saw some tissue paper, wrapped it around a pen, pulled the pen out, and thought, wow, this is actually better. They can take it home, modify it, and make different sizes. So that’s how that one came to be. It wasn’t a craft store journey.
Neely: You MacGyvered it.
Joint traction (1:01:00)
Jared: Should I do one last exercise for finger motion?
Neely: Yeah.
Jared: When the fingers are stiff, it’s usually coming from the joint. So the question is how to loosen up the finger joints without irritating them. Neely, you mentioned you have arthritis. Where is it, the tips of the fingers?
Neely: Yeah, the tip of my pointer finger, mostly.
Jared: Climbers most commonly get it first in the middle joint, the PIP, and some get it where you have it, in the DIP. So if a climber has a stiff joint, how do we loosen it? Motion is lotion is very global; you’re lubricating the joint by bending it back and forth. But how do you target the joint itself?
Neely: My PT told me to get a Chinese finger trap, put it on the end of my finger, and pull on it to traction it.
Jared: That’s a great way. Imagine the finger trap from when you were a kid, and I have some videos of this I can share. You slide the finger trap all the way onto the finger, then pull to target the joint. You usually do it either oscillating, back and forth, or sustained, a long steady pull, for about 45 seconds. If you’re oscillating, you go at two to three hertz, which is basically the tempo of “Row, Row, Row Your Boat.” There’s a whole methodology for treating joints like this, and I find it very useful.
There’s one challenge, though. Say you want to target the middle joint of the finger, so you put the finger trap on and pull. You’re also pulling on the joint closest to the palm, the MCP, at the same time. Since that joint is looser, most of the pull goes through it instead. Does that make sense?
Neely: Yeah, that’s what I experienced with the finger trap. So I just started doing it with my own hand.
Jared: You can isolate it with your own hand. But to isolate one joint, you need to bend it. If you keep the finger straight, you mobilize all the joints at once. That’s fine, but the stiff one won’t get the direct pressure, and you’ll likely mobilize the looser ones more.
The easiest way to do this, and remind me, Neely, I’ll send a video for this as well, is to put the finger over a countertop or a yoga block. I like a yoga block because it’s padded. Now the finger is draping over the edge right at the affected joint, and you can isolate your pull right on that joint, because the block is literally blocking all the other joints. Then you can do that pull back and forth and keep it isolated.
So if there’s a particularly stiff finger and you want to isolate it, use a yoga block or the edge of a desk, with a finger trap or your own hand. Or you can hang a weight from the finger trap, which works really well, as long as it doesn’t break. Everyone listening, be careful with this. Use a very light weight and consult a medical provider. But if you tape a 2.5-pound weight to a finger trap and dangle the finger off an edge, you get sustained traction on that joint without doing anything, and a little decompression in that area.
Neely: Oh, yeah. Tricky.
Jared: I’m not kidding that this could be a five-hour or even a ten-hour episode. There are so many things you can do. Those are just a few ideas: looking at a crimp, which is movement; looking at strength, which we talked about earlier; and a few ways to mobilize. For me, that’s the basis of how I treat every climber with an injury. It’s the basis of my book, The Resilient Climber. And in my opinion, it’s the basis of how we can reduce our risk of climbing injuries and climb longer and harder without pain.
Neely: Nice. That was a great masterclass.
Wrap-up (1:05:00)
Neely: Can people work with you right now?
Jared: Yes, definitely. It’s just me, so I have quite a waitlist. But if you’re in Los Angeles, send me a message. Or if you’re in Colorado, Utah, or California and you’d like a remote session, send me a message.
If I’m not available, I have a bunch of resources for other medical providers in different areas, and that’s on my webpage too. There are tons of excellent providers with really good training. I’m always happy to do my best to find somebody, because there are only so many hours in the day, and I split mine between clinical work and the university.
Neely: You do a lot.
Jared: It’s fun, though. It keeps me engaged. And now I’m climbing a ton, which makes the balance a little harder. I just got a second wave of huge motivation for some objectives in Yosemite, so I’m getting back at it.
Neely: That’s good. Happy for you. Where can people find you?
Jared: At theclimbingdoctor.com, you can find a lot of blog information and free programs. You can get The Resilient Climber wherever books are sold, and Climb Injury-Free, my original book, too. I’m also on TikTok and Instagram. And I have a Pinterest. I actually like Pinterest because it has all these single PDFs with pictures, so you can find me there as well.
Neely: Good to know. Lots of options. Well, thank you very much. I appreciate it, and we’ll talk soon about another body part.
Jared: All right, sounds good. Thanks, Neely.
